Robert M. Masters

Notable Matters

• Lead counsel for Qorvo, Inc. in a trade secret and patent infringement matter involving bulk acoustic wave filters against competitor Akoustis, Inc.. After a two-week jury trial in the U.S. District of Delaware, the jury returned a verdict in favor of Qorvo finding that Akoustis had willfully and maliciously misappropriated 39 of Qorvo’s trade secrets and infringed two patents. The jury awarded $38.6 million in monetary damages. In post-trial motions, the Court awarded Qorvo its attorneys’ fees, pre- and post-judgment interest, and a permanent injunction.
• Lead counsel for Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd. in a patent infringement action against Acushnet Company (“Titleist”) involving Titleist golf balls. The successful representation of Bridgestone Sports in this case was featured as the lead story in the book: Blaxill, Mark, and Ralph Eckardt. The Invisible Edge: Taking Your Strategy to the Next Level Using Intellectual Property. Portfolio, 2009.
• Lead counsel for Nidek in a series of matters involving excimer laser technology for vision correction, securing a complete defense victory and clean sweep against multiple competitors across U.S. district courts and the International Trade Commission.

Patent & Trade Secret Litigation

• Lead counsel for Aretech in a ten patent infringement matter filed by its competitor and plaintiff, Bioventus. After overcoming a motion to dismiss Aretech’s counterclaims against the plaintiff, the case settled on terms favorable to Aretech.
• Lead counsel for GDEP, a Gardner Denver company, in a patent infringement litigation matter involving design of fluid ends of an oil and gas pump. After a successful claim construction ruling and defeating a motion for summary judgment filed by the defendant, the case settled on terms favorable to GDEP.
• Lead counsel for Gas Control Equipment in a patent infringement matter involving portable oxygen concentrator. After two years of litigation, the case settled on terms favorable to GCE.
• Lead counsel for Cesca Therapeutics in a patent infringement matter involving point-of-care blood separation devices used to process and prepare cell concentrates from blood and bone marrow aspirates, and antitrust claims related to the filing of a sham litigation.
• Lead counsel for several major investors in DeltaWing Technologies, an innovator in the design of narrow-front-track automobiles, in matters involving theft of trade secrets and defamation.
• Lead counsel for HTI IP, LLC and Networkfleet, Inc. in a patent infringement matter involving vehicle telematics.
• Lead counsel for Konami Digital Entertainment in a patent infringement matter involving musical video games, including Rock Band® and Rock Revolution® rhythm games.
• Lead counsel for Waddell & Reed Financial in a patent infringement matter involving the interpretation of a general public license used for open source software and a copyright infringement action involving the right to use accounting software.
• Lead counsel for ESAB Group, Inc., a subsidiary of Colfax Corporation, in a matter involving claims of infringement of 11 patents and breach of contract/license agreement. The technology involved welding and cutting equipment. The case was filed against our client in the Eastern District of Wisconsin. After extensive discovery, we successfully resolved the case on terms favorable to our client.

Semiconductor, Telecom & High-Tech Disputes

• Lead counsel for two European manufacturers of semiconductor testing devices and probes in a patent infringement matter, and defending their patent before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board.
• Lead counsel for uCloudlink Co., Ltd., a Chinese telecommunication company, in a patent infringement matter involving mobile SIM sharing technologies, and defending their patents before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board.
• Lead counsel for NEC Corp. and NEC Corp. of America in patent infringement actions involving computer servers and network communications, protocols and establishing secure communications.
• Co-lead counsel for Samsung in a patent infringement matter involving chipsets used in smartphones and tablets.
• Lead counsel for leading companies, including Ford Motor Company, Goldman Sachs, Petco, Johnson & Johnson, GlaxoSmithKline, Delta Airlines, AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP and others in a series of patent infringement actions involving authenticating and securing communications over a network.
• Lead counsel for Japanese manufacturer in a patent infringement action involving semiconductor memory devices.

PTAB & Post-Grant Proceedings

• Lead counsel for a Japanese company in a series of inter partes reviews (IPRs) of several patents directed to semiconductor design/process patents.
• Lead counsel for European manufacture of semiconductor test equipment in a series of inter partes reviews.
• Lead counsel for industrial company in an inter partes review of patents relating to portable oxygen concentrators.
• Lead counsel for semiconductor company in a series of inter partes review of patents relating to the design and manufacture of semiconductors.

ITC & Anti-Counterfeiting Enforcement

• Lead counsel for Flexsys America, LP in a patent infringement action involving antidegradients used for tires and other rubber products.
• Lead counsel for Pacific Bioscience, a L’Oreal company, in a patent and trade dress infringement matter involving the company’s highly successful line of Clarisonic products. In this matter, we represented Pacific Bioscience in actions filed in U.S. District Court and the U.S. International Trade Commission to stop the importation of counterfeits and infringing devices by over 20 companies into the U.S., and to obtain a general exclusion order against all other infringing products.

Licensing, Arbitration & IP Strategy

• Lead counsel for leading ESAB Group, Ltd. in an international arbitration under the ICC in Zurich, Switzerland. The case involves allegations of breach of technology and license agreements involving the manufacture and sale of consumable welding equipment.
• Lead counsel for an Asian joint venture entity in a matter involving the licensing of optical disk drives and related components, including issues of standard essential patents (SEPs) and fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory licensing (FRAND) agreements.
• Lead counsel for Wacom Co., Ltd., a Japanese consumer electronics company, to assist in the enforcement and licensing of its standard essential patent portfolio and representation of the company before a standard setting organization on technology relating to stylus and touch displays.
• Counseled a multi-billion dollar company in an over-haul of its intellectual property department by utilizing IP corporate best practices and strategies to institute new policies and practices to build and maintain a robust patent/trademark portfolio.

Litigator of the Week Runner-ups, ALM in May 24, 2024 for winning the $38.6 million jury verdict for Qorvo against rival Akoustis.

Leading Individual - Intellectual Property, Chambers USA

Leading Lawyer - Patent Litigation, Legal 500