On November 12, Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday announced a $183.5 million multistate settlement resolving allegations against a rent-to-own provider. Pennsylvania’s complaint alleges violations of the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law and the Pennsylvania Rental-Purchase Agreement Act.
The complaint alleges that the provider misled consumers about the cost and terms of its rental-purchase agreements. Specifically, the provider allegedly:
- Misrepresented payoff options and costs. Advertised agreements as 90-day “same as cash” or interest-free programs while automatically setting consumers up for payments over the maximum term, which often totaled at least twice the merchandise’s cash price. The advertising allegedly did not explain that consumers had to contact the provider and change their payments to use the 90-day purchase option.
- Mischaracterized the agreements and credit inquiry. Described the agreements as loans, credit, or financing without clearly identifying them as rent-to-own transactions. The provider also allegedly advertised that applications did not require a credit check, despite conducting a soft inquiry on each application.
- Obscured terms and marked up cash prices. Failed to adequately train retail partners or clearly explain the agreements’ costs and payment options in electronic disclosures. The complaint also alleges the provider’s signing process could prompt consumers to sign without viewing the full agreement and that it marked up retailers’ cash prices by as much as about $100.
- Reported inaccurate credit information and obstructed disputes. Reported the maximum-term payment amount as outstanding debt even when consumers could pay less through an early purchase option or by returning the merchandise. The provider allegedly lacked adequate procedures for investigating consumer disputes.
- Mishandled merchandise, servicing, and termination. Charged consumers when merchandise had not been fully delivered or was damaged, sometimes failed to repair or replace damaged items, and obstructed consumers’ ability to terminate agreements by returning merchandise. The complaint also alleges misrepresentations about payment-processing delays and threats of seizure or legal action.
The settlement includes $43 million for consumer restitution, $10.5 million for the states, and $130 million in lease-balance reductions. Pennsylvania consumers are expected to receive more than $1.6 million in restitution and $3.6 million in lease forgiveness. The proposed judgment also requires changes to advertising and disclosures, retailer training, cash-price practices, termination procedures, and credit reporting. Pennsylvania’s executed proposed consent judgment is pending court approval and states that the provider is entering into similar judgments with the other participating states. The provider did not admit liability.
Putting It Into Practice: State scrutiny of rent-to-own disclosures, costs, and servicing continues to be a focus of enforcement activity (previously discussed here). Providers and retail partners should review their advertising, disclosures, signing processes, training, and return procedures under applicable state laws.
*Sammy Abdulrahim is a law clerk in the firm's Washington, D.C. office.